Michael Gorman, A Critique of Bischoff's Theory of Irish Exegesis: the Commentary on Genesis in Munich Clm 6302 (Wendepunkte 2). In The Journal of Medieval Latin. A Publication of the North American Association of Medieval Latin, Brepols 7 (1997) 178-233.
Keywords
Bernhard Bischoff | Freising | Genesis commentaries | Hiberno-Latin exegesis | Irish symptoms | Isidore | Manuscripts | Wendepunkte cataloguecreation |
methodology | scholarship |
References
Ailerán (p. 192)
Ambrose (pp. 182, 184, 204 n.85, 209, 210)
Augustine (pp. 179 n.5, 180 n.6, 182 n.8, 184, 189, 190 n.23, 193 n.29, 195 n.37, n.39, 202-203, 205, 206, 209, 210 n.108)
Augustinus Hibernicus (p. 193 n.29)
Bede (pp. 180 n.6, 184 n.13, 187, 190, 195, 199, 202 n.61, 203, 204 n.83, 206 n.91, n.92, 207 n.93)
Byrthferth (p. 203 n.79)
Christian of Stavelot (p. 203)
Colmán (p. 198)
Columbanus (p. 198)
Claudius of Turin (pp. 188, 203, 204, 206, 210)
CuimÖne Ailbe (p. 181 n.7)
Comianus Longus (p. 181 n.7)
Cummian (p. 181 n.7) Cummeanus, alledged author of Mark commentary (pp. 180-181, 191)
Defensor of Ligugé (p. 179 n.5)
Eucherius (pp. 202 n.62, 204 n.86)
Gennadius (p. 180 n.5)
Gregory (pp. 180 n.5, 182, 184, 189, 192, 195, 202-203)
Hadrian of Nisida (p.191)
Heiric of Auxerre (p. 203)
Israel the Grammarian (p. 198)
Isidore (pp. 180 n.5, n.6, 183 n.10, 184-190, 193 n.29, 194, 195, 198 n.50, 201-204, 207, 208 n.98, 210)
Iunillus (p. 205 n.86)
Jerome (pp. 182, 184, 189, 202, 209)
John Cassian (p. 202)
John Scottus Eriugena (pp. 196-197, 202 n.61)
Laidcenn mac Baíth Bannaig (p. 192)
Manchianus / Manchene (p. 192 n.29)
Origen (p. 210)
Paschasius Radbertus (p. 203)
Pseudo-Bede (pp. 188, 194, 204)
Pseudo-Hilary (p. 203)
Pseudo-Jerome (pp. 179-181, 191, 194, 198, 207)
Remigius of Auxerre (pp. 187, 202 n.61)
Sedulius (p. 198 n.49)
Sedulius Scottus (pp. 196-197, 203)
Theodore of Canterbury (pp. 190-191)
Theodulf of Orléans (p. 180 n.5)
Virgilius Maro Grammaticus (pp. 182-183, 185-186, 194 n.33)
Wigbod (pp. 183 n.10, 201 n.57, 204 n.83, 206, 210)
Locations
Albi, Bibliothèque Municipale, 29 (p. 208 n.96, n.98)
Angers, Bibliothèque municipale, 55, f. 7r (pp. 181, 191)
Angers, Bibliothèque municipale, 225, ff. 44v-63v (p. 180 n.6)
Autun, Bibliothèque Municipale, 27 (S.29) (pp. 184 n.12, 193 n.29, 211 n.113)
Basel, Universitätsbibliothek, F. III. 15b, ff. 1r-19r (p. 179 n.5)
Berlin, Deutsche Staatsbibliothek, Diez. B. 66 (p. 201 n.57)
Berlin, Deutsche Staatsbibliothek, Phillipps 1651 (pp. 179 n.5, 190 n.23)
Cambrai, Bibliothèque municipale, 679 (p.185)
Cologne, Historisches Archiv, W f§ 144, ff. 91r-114v (p. 193 n. 29)
Karlsruhe, Badische Landesbibliothek, Aug. CXCI, ff. 132r-150v (p. 193 n.29)
Karlsruhe, Badische Landesbibliothek, Aug. CCXXXIII (p. 203)
Lyons, Bibliothèque Municipale, 447 (376) (p. 207)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 3824 (pp. 179 n.5, 109 n.23)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 6286 (p. 207)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 6302 (p. 179), ff. 1r-29v (p. 179), ff. 29v-46r (pp. 180, 182), ff. 46v-49r (p. 180),
ff. 49r-64r (throughout), ff. 64r-69v (p. 181)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 6307 (p. 207)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 6319 (p. 207)
Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 17739 (pp. 205-206)
Orléans, Bibliothèque Municipale, 65 (62) pp. 1-269 (p. 197 n.43)
Oxford, Bodleian Library, lat. th.c. 26, ff. 60v-75r (p. 193 n.29)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 528 (p. 205 n.89)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 614 A (pp. 207, 208 n.96)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 2175 (p. 208 n.96, n.98)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 2342 (pp. 204 n.83, 206 n.92)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 3848B (p. 180 n.5)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 9561, ff. 1r-14r (p. 180 n.5)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 10457 (p. 208)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 10612 (p. 208 n.96)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 10616 (p. 208 n.98)
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, lat. 15679, pp. 350-354 (p. 180 n.6)
Salisbury, Cathedral Library, 115 (p. 208 n.96)
St Gallen, Stiftsbibliothek, 908 (pp. 187, 207, 208, 211)
Vercelli, Biblioteca Capitolare, 121 (pp. 187, 205-206)
Verona, Biblioteca Capitolare, XXVII (p. 208)
Vienna, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, lat. 940, ff. 13r-141v (p. 197 n.43)
Vienna, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, lat. 997, ff. 1r-66v (p. 203), ff. 67r-84v (p. 203)
Documents
Aduersus Iouinianum [Jerome] (p. 209 n.103)
Cambrai Homily (p. 185)
Canon euangeliorum [Ailerán] (p. 192)
Carmen paschale [Sedulius] (p. 198 n.49)
Collectaneum in omnes beati Pauli epistolas [Sedulius Scottus] (p. 203)
Commemoratio Geneseos (pp. 187, 207, 208-211)
Commentary on the Catholic Epistles, Karlsruhe Aug. CCXXXIII (p. 203)
Commentary on the Creation and the Fall (pp. 187, 207-208, 211)
Commentary on Genesis, Autun 27 (S.29) (pp. 193 n.29, 210 n.113)
Commentary on Genesis [Claudius of Turin] (pp. 188, 204)
Commentary on Genesis I-XXXIV (throughout)
Commentary on Genesis [Wigbod] (p.206 n.92)
Commentary on Kings [Isidore] (p. 207)
Commentary on Kings [Claudius of Turin] (p. 204 n.85)
Conlationes [John Cassian] (p. 202)
De ciuitate dei [Augustine] (pp. 205, 206)
De controuerisa paschali [Cummian] (p. 181 n.7)
De ecclesiasticis dogmatibus [Gennadius] (p. 180 n.5)
De Genesi ad litteram [Augustine] (pp. 179 n.5, 193 n.29, 195 n.37, 209, 210 n.107)
De Genesi contra Manichaeos [Augustine] (pp. 189, 195 n.37)
De fide trinitate [Isidore] (p. 180 n.5)
De institutis coenobiorum [John Cassian] (p. 202 n.63)
De mirabilibus sacrae scripturae [Augustinus Hibernicus] (pp. 192, 193 n.29)
De natura rerum [Isidore] (pp. 185, 208 n.98)
De ordine creaturarum (pp. 179, 197, 206-207)
De partibus diuinae legis [Iunillus] (p. 205 n.86)
De ratione conputandi (p. 181 n.7)
De tabernaculo [Bede] (p. 203 n.69)
De tempore rationum [Bede] (p. 187)
De trinitate [Augustine] (p. 203 n.80)
Differentiae [Isidore] (p. 203)
Egloga de moralibus in Iob [Laidcenn mac Baíth Bannaig] (p. 192)
Enchiridion [Byrthferth] (p. 203 n.79)
Epistolae [Augustine] (p. 203 n.80)
Epitomae [Virgilius Maro] (pp. 182-3, 185-186)
Etymologiae [Isidore] (pp. 186, 187 n.19, 188, 202-203, 204 n.81)
Exameron [Ambrose] (pp. 204 n.85, 209)
Explanatio sex dierum (pp. 183 n.10, 188, 194, 210)
Expositio euangelii secundum Marcum [Pseudo-Jerome / Cummeanus] (pp. 179-181, 191, 194, 198, 207)
Expositio in Canticum Canticorum [Gregory] (p. 203)
Expositio in euangelium Matthaei [Christian of Stavelot] (p. 203)
Expositio in Matheo [Paschasius Radbertus] (p. 203)
Expositio in lamentationes Hieremiae [Paschasius Radbertus] (p. 203)
Expositio in VII epistolas canonicas [Pseudo-Hilary] (p. 203)
Expositio IV euangeliorum [Pseudo-Jerome] (pp. 194, 198)
Formulae [Eucherius] (p. 202 n.62)
Genealogium Iesu Christi secundum carnem (pp. 180, 182, 183, 184)
Glosses [Theodore and Hadrian] (pp. 190, 191)
Hexaemeron [Bede] (p. 195 n.37)
In Genesim homiliae [Origen] (p. 210)
In Iohannis euangelium tractatus [Augustine] (pp. 180 n.6, 195 n.39)
In Lucae euangelium expositio [Bede] (p. 203 n.69)
In Pentateuchum Commentarii [Pseudo-Bede] (pp. 184 n.13, 188, 190 n.23, 194, 204, 206 n.91, 207 n.93)
In Samuelem prophetam allegorica expositio [Bede] (p. 203 n.69)
Incipit prebiarum de multorium exemplaribus (p. 181)
Instructiones [Eucherius] (p. 204 n.86)
Interpretatio mystica progenitorum domini Iesu Christi et Interpretatio moralis progenitorum domini Iesu Christi [Ailerán]
(p. 192)
Lections on the Hexateuch [Pseudo-Bede?] (pp. 204 n.83, 206, n.92)
Liber de numeris [Pseudo-Isidore] (p. 197)
Liber questionum in euangeliis (p. 197 n.43)
Liber scintillarum [Defensor of Ligugé] (p. 179 n.5)
Moralia in Iob [Gregory] (pp. 184, 192)
Pauca problesmata de enigmatibus ex tomis canonicis [Reference Bible, Bibelwerk] (pp. 178, 187, 191, 194, 198, 204, 205, 207)
Quaestiones in vetus Testamentum [including Commentary on Genesis] [Isidore] (pp. 180 n.6, 184, 187, 188, 189, 194, 202, 204,
207, 210)
Quaestiones Orosii et responsiones Augustini (pp. 181, 194, 204)
Quaestiones on the Pentateuch Paris lat. 528 (p. 205 n.89)
Quaestiones hebraicae in Genesim [Jerome] (pp. 182, 209)
Regula pastoralis [Gregory] (pp. 180 n.5, 202)
Retractio in Actus apostolorum [Bede] (p. 203 n.69)
XXX Quaestiones [Bede] (p. 180 n.6)
Sententiae [Isidore] (p. 203)
Sermones [Augustine] (p. 203 n.80)
Vercelli Sermons on Genesis (pp.187, 205-206)
Sermons on Genesis Clm 17739 (pp. 205-206)
Vienna Commentary on John (p. 203)
Vienna Commentary on Luke (p. 203)
Vienna Commentary on Matthew (p. 197 n.43)
Virtutes Heliae et Helisaei (p. 198)
Vitae patrum (pp. 182, 184)
Names
Angers (p. 191)
Britain (p. 185 n.16, 194)
Brittany (p. 198)
Burgundy (p. 180 n.5)
Canterbury (pp. 190-191)
England (pp. 180 n.5, 193 n.29)
England, north (p. 179 n.5)
Flavigny (p. 180 n.5)
France (pp. 180 n.6, 194)
Freising (pp. 178-179, 183, 184, 206, 207)
Fulda (p. 179 n.5)
Germany (p.194)
Ireland (throughout)
Italy (p. 194), Italy, north (p. 207), Italy, northwest (p. 205)
Lake Constance (p. 193 n.29)
Lismore (p. 197)
Mondrehid (p. 192 n.29)
Milan (p. 207)
Munich (p. 190)
Nicea (pp. 188-189)
Orléans (p. 180 n.6)
Reichenau (p. 193 n.29)
St Bertin (p. 180 n.5)
St Denis (p. 205 n.89)
Spain (pp. 179 n.5, 194, 195, 201)
Switzerland (p. 194)
Toledo (p. 179 n.5)
Verona (pp. 201 n.57, 208, 209 n.101)
Vienna (p. 190)
Index
Abel and Christ: 221189, 226-231
Adam and Christ: 216
Adam and Eve as Christ and Church: 216, 217
Apostles as Noah's sons: 224
Ark's wood and cross: 222-223
Cain and Abel: 189, 221
Dinah: 190, 232-233
Isaac and Christ: 190, 231
Jacob and angel: 190, 231
Jacob's ladder: 190, 231
Lamech: 189, 222
Lot: 230
Mathusalah: 189, 222189, 227
Noah's Ark: 189, 217, 222-226
Paradise: 189, 217
Sarah's laughter: 189, 229
Sodom: 230224
Verbum: 212
angels on Jacob's ladder: 231218, 222
birds: 217185, 226
blue: 185, 226
covenant of the rainbow: 189, 225
creation, date of: 187, 213
cross and iota: 187, 227
denarius: 230225
earth: 185, 212, 215231
fifty: 230214
flood and baptism: 222
forty days: 224
four leges: 204
light and darkness: 213-214
locus tempus persona: 202, 206
penance: 188, 213, 230, 232185, 226
reptiles: 217
rivers of Paradise: 217-218
serpent as devil: 219-220231
six ages of the world: 189, 216-217
six days of creation: 189, 216
sky: 212
stars: 215, 228
thirty cubits of the Ark: 223186
three ages: 203
three colours of martyrdom: 185, 226
three ecclesiastical orders: 186, 223, 224
three hundred and eighteen bishops: 188, 226-227
three leges: 204
three sacred languages: 202
three temptations: 220
three ways to overcome temptations: 220
tree of Paradise: 218, 219, 220
twelve sons of Jacob: 232
twelve steps of Jacob's ladder: 231-232
uita theorica, uita actualis: 185, 202, 203, 212185, 226
Joseph F. Kelly, A Catalogue of Early Medieval Hiberno-Latin Biblical Commentaries (I). In Traditio 44 (1988) 537-571.
Joseph F. Kelly, A Catalogue of Early Medieval Hiberno-Latin Biblical Commentaries (II). In Traditio 45 (1989) 393-434.
Charles D. Wright, Bischoff's Theory of Irish Exegesis and the Genesis Commentary in Munich Clm 6302: A Critique of a Critique. In The Journal of Medieval Latin. A Publication of the North American Association of Medieval Latin, Brepols, Turnhout 10 (2001) 2000, 115-175, 2-503-50956-8.