Regional Variation in Irish Pre-Romanesque Architecture

Typeset version

 

TY  - JOUR
  - Tomás Ó Carragáin
  - 2005
  - July
  - Antiquaries Journal
  - Regional Variation in Irish Pre-Romanesque Architecture
  - Published
  - ()
  - 85
  - 23
  - 56
  - This paper demonstrates that the five Irish early medieval church types have markedly differential distributions. In particular, most of those with antae are in the east, while most of those without antae are in the west. It is shown that this regionalism cannot be interpreted as a deliberate strategy of material differentiation on the part of particular politico-cultural groups. A reconsideration of the chronology suggests that many of the antae-less churches are relatively late, and so the division is primarily indicative of differences in the period and rate of mortared church construction, something that is influenced by both environmental and cultural factors. It is suggested that differences in church dimensions between east and west are indicative of subtle economic differences; and a range of archaeological evidence is used to sketch other economic and cultural variations. These patterns highlight the importance of exploring regionality, even when studying relatively cohesive entities such as early medieval Ireland.
  - London
  - 10.1017/S0003581500074369
DA  - 2005/07
ER  - 
@article{V346592,
   = {Tomás Ó Carragáin },
   = {2005},
   = {July},
   = {Antiquaries Journal},
   = {Regional Variation in Irish Pre-Romanesque Architecture},
   = {Published},
   = {()},
   = {85},
  pages = {23--56},
   = {{This paper demonstrates that the five Irish early medieval church types have markedly differential distributions. In particular, most of those with antae are in the east, while most of those without antae are in the west. It is shown that this regionalism cannot be interpreted as a deliberate strategy of material differentiation on the part of particular politico-cultural groups. A reconsideration of the chronology suggests that many of the antae-less churches are relatively late, and so the division is primarily indicative of differences in the period and rate of mortared church construction, something that is influenced by both environmental and cultural factors. It is suggested that differences in church dimensions between east and west are indicative of subtle economic differences; and a range of archaeological evidence is used to sketch other economic and cultural variations. These patterns highlight the importance of exploring regionality, even when studying relatively cohesive entities such as early medieval Ireland.}},
   = {London},
   = {10.1017/S0003581500074369},
  source = {IRIS}
}
AUTHORSTomás Ó Carragáin
YEAR2005
MONTHJuly
JOURNAL_CODEAntiquaries Journal
TITLERegional Variation in Irish Pre-Romanesque Architecture
STATUSPublished
TIMES_CITED()
SEARCH_KEYWORD
VOLUME85
ISSUE
START_PAGE23
END_PAGE56
ABSTRACTThis paper demonstrates that the five Irish early medieval church types have markedly differential distributions. In particular, most of those with antae are in the east, while most of those without antae are in the west. It is shown that this regionalism cannot be interpreted as a deliberate strategy of material differentiation on the part of particular politico-cultural groups. A reconsideration of the chronology suggests that many of the antae-less churches are relatively late, and so the division is primarily indicative of differences in the period and rate of mortared church construction, something that is influenced by both environmental and cultural factors. It is suggested that differences in church dimensions between east and west are indicative of subtle economic differences; and a range of archaeological evidence is used to sketch other economic and cultural variations. These patterns highlight the importance of exploring regionality, even when studying relatively cohesive entities such as early medieval Ireland.
PUBLISHER_LOCATIONLondon
ISBN_ISSN
EDITION
URL
DOI_LINK10.1017/S0003581500074369
FUNDING_BODY
GRANT_DETAILS